Ex Parte Peter et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2006-0440                                                        
          Application No. 10/291,933                                                  

               Claim 1, step ii), recites in part: “the outlet streams                
          being applied to the substrate and the outlet streams being                 
          spaced apart from each other such that the outlet streams flow              
          together seamlessly after application to the substrate.”  Thus,             
          the recitation specifies two limitations: (1) the outlet streams            
          are applied to the substrate; and (2) the outlet streams are                
          spaced apart from each other such that they flow together                   
          seamlessly after application to the substrate.  By its express              
          terms, however, the first limitation does not specify the                   
          particular physical forms of the outlet streams.  That is, the              
          limitation does not recite that the outlet streams are applied              
          to the substrate individually and separately.  Hence, we                    
          construe the first limitation to read on or encompass a step in             
          which the outlet streams are combined at the time that they are             
          applied to the substrate.  Similarly, with respect to the second            
          limitation, there is no requirement that the outlet streams must            
          be spaced apart immediately prior to their application to the               
          substrate.  The limitation merely requires that the outlet                  
          streams are spaced apart at some point in time but that they                
          flow seamlessly after application to the substrate.                         
               Our interpretation of the claim language is consistent with            
          the specification description, which indicates to one skilled in            

                                          5                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007