Ex Parte Peter et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2006-0440                                                        
          Application No. 10/291,933                                                  

               iii) effecting relative movement between the rotating body             
                    and the sheet die in a direction parallel to the axis             
                    of rotation; and                                                  
               iv) synchronizing the rate of reaction of the reaction                 
                    mixture and the relative movement with the                        
                    circumferential speed of the rotating body in such a              
                    way that successive convolutions overlap in the form              
                    of scales and connect together seamlessly.                        
          (Column 1, line 50 column 2, line 17.)  Grimm further teaches               
          that the circumferential speed at the largest diameter of the               
          coating to be applied is preferably adjusted to be less than the            
          speed at which the reaction mixture emerges from the sheet die.             
          (Column 3, lines 41-45.)  Thus, one of ordinary skill in the art            
          would have understood that the substrate is rotated at a                    
          selected speed.                                                             
               As the examiner correctly points out (answer at 3), Grimm’s            
          method differs from a method encompassed by appealed claim 1                
          only in that step ii) of the prior art method does not involve              
          the use of a die that divides “an inlet stream of the polymeric             
          reaction mixture into plural outlet streams, the outlet streams             
          being applied to the substrate and the outlet streams being                 
          spaced apart from each other such that the outlet streams flow              

                                          7                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007