Ex Parte 6254978 et al - Page 9




               Appeal No. 2006-0791                                            Ex parte Gore Enterp. Holdings, Inc.                   
                       Silva                                                                                                          
                       [43]    Silva teaches an ion-exchange membrane based on a microporous PTFE sheet                               
               (Silva at, e.g., 1:32-44).                                                                                             
                       [44]    Silva teaches (at 6:13-17) a PTFE ion-exchange membrane that is 01.-10 mils,                           
               preferably 0.5-3.0 mils, thick.                                                                                        
                       [45]    Like Ito, Silva is directed to solving the problem of providing an effective thin                      
               ion-exchange membrane with adequate mechanical strength (Silva at, e.g., 1:10-28).                                     
                       [46]    Augmented mechanical strength is sufficient motivation to use PTFE as the                              
               material for the membrane of Ito.                                                                                      
                       [47]    Silva discloses that PTFE film can be processed at temperatures well in excess of                      
               140°C (at 7:51-52; at 8:7-9).                                                                                          
                       Mallouk                                                                                                        
                       [48]    Mallouk teaches (at 1:62-66):                                                                          
                       [a] porous composite membrane...comprising a film of porous, expanded                                          
                       polytetrafluoroethylene whose surfaces, both exterior and within its pores, are                                
                       coated with a metal salt of perfluoro-cation exchange polymer.                                                 
                       [49]    Mallouk's metal salt is a perfluoro-cation exchange resin (at 2:49-55).                                
                       [50]    Mallouk's film has a thickness of 1-6 mils and a porosity exceeding 60%                                
               (at 2:6-12).                                                                                                           
                       [51]    Mallouk is concerned with making a nerve-gas sensor (at 1:6-10).                                       
                       [52]    Mallouk's membrane is specifically designed to permit air flow through the                             
               membrane (at 2:15-24).                                                                                                 


                                                                - 9 -                                                                 





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007