Ex Parte Paul et al - Page 10



                 Appeal No. 2006-0894                                                                                Page 10                       
                 Application No. 10/412,840                                                                                                        

                 regard, we note that the information conveyed by the disclosure                                                                   
                 of using Mylar as a substrate in Erickson includes that which                                                                     
                 would be intrinsically conveyed thereby, including the moisture                                                                   
                 holding properties of Mylar.                    3                                                                                 
                         Here, appellants have not argued, much less offered any                                                                   
                 evidence to establish, that Mylar does not intrinsically possess                                                                  
                 a low moisture content within any of those claimed ranges.  As                                                                    
                 such, we shall also affirm the examiner’s anticipation rejection                                                                  
                 of each of separately argued dependent claims 4, 5 and 18.                                                                        
                 Claims 13, 6, 17, 22, 23 and 24                                                                                                   
                 We select claim 13 as representative of this claim grouping.                                                                      
                 Concerning this claim grouping and representative claim 13, we                                                                    
                 note that appellants maintain that Erickson does not disclose the                                                                 
                 less than about 5 percent moisture content substrate and the                                                                      
                 maintaining thereof during the curing of the adhesive limitations                                                                 
                 of representative claim 13.  However, as discussed above,                                                                         
                 Erickson discloses the use of a Mylar substrate, which substrate                                                                  
                 would intrinsically possess low moisture characteristics,                                                                         
                 including possessing a moisture content as low as here claimed                                                                    
                 whether before or during the curing step.  This is an intrinsic                                                                   

                         3See footnote 1 and Table 7 of Kirk-Othmer under the                                                                      
                 caption Moisture absorption across from “polyester (Mylar).                                                                       





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007