Ex Parte Paul et al - Page 5



                 Appeal No. 2006-0894                                                                                  Page 5                      
                 Application No. 10/412,840                                                                                                        

                         Appellants do not dispute that Erickson discloses, inter                                                                  
                 alia, a process for coating and curing an adhesive on a substrate                                                                 
                 or liner.  Moreover, the examiner has found that Erickson’s                                                                       
                 adhesive is both pressure sensitive and cationic curable, as                                                                      
                 required in representative claim 1.  Appellants do not contest                                                                    
                 that determination by the examiner.  Rather, appellants maintain                                                                  
                 that: (1) Erickson does not disclose using a backing substrate or                                                                 
                 release liner that has low moisture content, and (2) Erickson                                                                     
                 does not disclose that the adhesive coated substrate/liner is                                                                     
                 allowed to cure under low moisture conditions, as recited in                                                                      
                 claim 1.  We disagree.                                                                                                            
                         As generally explained by the examiner in the answer (pages                                                               
                 3-8), Erickson discloses using Mylar , an intrinsically low   1                                                                   
                 moisture content film material, as a substrate/liner on which the                                                                 
                 adhesive, an epoxidized block copolymer, is coated and cured.                                                                     
                 See, e.g., Examples 1-6 of Erickson and the other portions of                                                                     
                 Erickson referred to by the examiner in the answer.  The                                                                          
                 representative claim 1 requirement for a low moisture content                                                                     

                         1Mylar is a polyester plastic film that intrinsically                                                                     
                 possesses the property of low moisture absorption.  See Kirk-                                                                     
                 Othmer, Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology (fourth edition),                                                                     
                 Volume 17, pages 1034-36, particularly Table 7 at page 1034 (copy                                                                 
                 attached).                                                                                                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007