Ex Parte Paul et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 2006-0894                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 10/412,840                                                  

               We reach essentially the same result with respect to                   
          appellants’ contention that Erickson does not disclose the                  
          representative claim 1 limitation requiring that the cure of the            
          coated substrate is allowed to occur under low moisture                     
          conditions.  Concerning this matter, we agree with the examiner             
          for reasons set forth in the answer that Erickson clearly                   
          describes curing the applied coating in a fashion that the                  
          claimed “low moisture” condition cure reads on.  In this regard,            
          we note, for instance, that Example 5 of Erickson (column 19,               
          line 62 through column 20, line 21) describes coating the                   
          adhesive onto sheets of Mylar to form dry coating formulation               
          samples that are irradiated after preheating to remove any                  
          moisture.  As further described in the above referenced portion             
          of the description of Example 5 of Erickson, a nitrogen blanket             
          is employed during the curing.  In addition, Erickson (see, e.g.,           
          table 7 and Example 5 at column 20, line 22 through column 21,              
          line 3 of the applied patent) describes the coating and curing of           
          adhesives, as claimed, onto a Mylar substrate/liner in a manner             
          that results in a functional product; that is, a product that has           
          adequate gel formation and cohesive strength and shear                      
          resistance, properties that are consistent with low moisture                
          conditions during the curing of the adhesive, as evidenced by               





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007