Ex Parte Debaty et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2006-0927                                                        
          Application No. 09/949,488                                                  
               The examiner does not mention in the statement of the                  
          rejection exactly what portion of Gabber he is relying on for the           
          claim limitations “receiving an HTTP request from the user for              
          information from a Web server;” and “adding the user context                
          information to the HTTP request,” and it is the “adding the user            
          context information to the HTTP request” which is argued by                 
          appellants as distinguishing over Gabber.                                   

               Thus, the issue before us is whether Gabber does, indeed,              
          disclose “adding the user context information to the HTTP request,”         
          as claimed.                                                                 

               The examiner contends that Gabber does disclose this                   
          limitation because Gabber is interested in receiving customized web         
          page responses while allowing the user to remain anonymous to that          
          web site (taught in the Abstract of Gabber).  In achieving this             
          function, Gabber is said by the examiner to receive requests for            
          web information from a browser and include/add substitute                   
          identifiers to the HTTP headers of the request received from the            
          browser, identifying column 6, lines 5-11, of Gabber.                       

               The examiner reasons that although the substitute identifier           
          in Gabber replaces information in the HTTP header, this substitute          
                                          4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007