Ex Parte Debaty et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2006-0927                                                        
          Application No. 09/949,488                                                  
          show a HTTP request, and this is admitted by appellants (reply              
          brief-page 2), but appellants are arguing that Gabber does not show         
          or suggest adding or appending information (user context                    
          information) to an HTTP request.  It is appellants’ position that           
          Gabber only removes, or filters, information from HTTP headers and          
          “removing” or “filtering” does not constitute “adding.”                     

               We agree with the examiner’s rationale, at pages 7-8 of the            
          answer, citing column 6, lines 5-11 of Gabber.  From column 5, line         
          58, through column 6, line 11, of Gabber, it is described that the          
          substitute identifiers are indirectly provided by a central proxy           
          system 110a to a server site 110g and that site-specific substitute         
          identifiers are provided.  Some of the executable routines provided         
          by the central proxy system are a transmission of the substitute            
          identifiers to server site 110g and a removal (and/or substitution)         
          of portions of the browsing commands that would identify user site          
          105a to server site 110g.  Thus, it would appear that, at least             
          indirectly, the substitute identifiers are added to the HTTP                
          request.  Note again that we interpret “adding” to mean that the            
          substitute identifiers were not in the HTTP request before and now          
          they are.  That, in our estimation, constitutes an “addition” even          
          though other information, for which these identifiers are                   
          substituted, may be removed.                                                
                                          7                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007