Ex Parte Schena et al - Page 10



         Appeal No. 2006-1831                                                       
         Application No. 09/755,383                                                 
              2. At column 3, line 64 through column 4, line 6,                     
              Hannaford states that:                                                
                   Referring to FIG. 2, an operator uses a pen-like or              
                   other tool 14 to apply forces/displacements to the               
                   control point 12. The manipulator 10 responds to the             
                   applied forces allowing control point 12 movement with           
                   three degrees of freedom within a workspace 16. The              
                   control point 12 is defined at an end-effector 18. The           
                   manipulator 10 includes a planar structure 20 enabling           
                   motion in an xy plane to define two degrees of freedom.          
                   The planar structure 20 is moved along a z-axis by               
                   actuators 22, 24 to define a third degree of freedom.            
              3. At column 1, lines 52 through 63, Hannaford states                 
              that:                                                                 
                   A force feedback device also is referred to as a force           
                   display. In the computer field the term display refers           
                   to a visual output device upon which ephemeral images            
                   are shown. The display serves as a visual interface              
                   between an end user and a computer environment. An               
                   operator uses his visual sense to experience the                 
                   images. Analogously, the term "force display" is coined          
                   to refer to an output device upon which ephemeral                
                   forces are exhibited. The force display serves as a              
                   force-reflective, haptic, kinaesthetic, or tactile               
                   interface between an operator and a real or simulated            
                   environment. The operator uses his sense of touch to             
                   experience the forces.                                           
              With the above discussion in mind, we find that the                   
         Hannaford reference substantially teaches the claimed invention.           
         Hannaford teaches a pen-like tool for interfacing with a direct            
         drive manipulator, whereby said pen-like tool is able to move and          
         apply a force onto the surface of the direct drive manipulator.            

                                         10                                         




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007