Ex Parte Nesbitt - Page 2


                 Appeal 2006-1941                                                                                    
                 Application 09/877,835                                                                              

                                                THE INVENTION                                                        
                        The appellant claims a golf ball.  Claim 1 is illustrative:                                  
                        1.  A golf ball comprising:                                                                  
                        a multi-layer core comprising a center component and a                                       
                        core layer disposed about said center component, wherein said                                
                        center component of said multi-layer core is softer relative to                              
                        said core layer;                                                                             
                        wherein said center component comprises a thermoset                                          
                        material and said core layer comprises a thermoset material;                                 
                        and,                                                                                         
                              a cover layer disposed about said multi-layer core;                                    
                        wherein said cover layer includes one of (i) a multi-layer                                   
                        cover comprising an inner cover layer having a Shore D                                       
                        hardness of 65 or greater and an outer cover layer having a                                  
                        Shore D hardness of 65 or less, said inner cover layer being                                 
                        harder than said outer cover layer, (ii) a multi-layer cover                                 
                        comprising an inner cover layer having a Shore D hardness of                                 
                        65 or less and an outer cover layer of 65 or greater, wherein                                
                        said inner cover layer is softer than said outer cover layer, (iii) a                        
                        single non-ionomeric outer cover layer having a Shore D                                      
                        hardness of from about 40 to 80, and (iv) a single ionomeric                                 
                        outer cover layer having a Shore D hardness of at least 56.                                  
                                               THE REFERENCES                                                        
                 Yamagishi           5,688,595         Nov. 18, 1997                                                 
                 Melvin             5,779,562         Jul.   14, 1998                                                
                 Science and Golf III, Proceedings of the 1998 World Scientific Congress of                          
                 Golf 441-42 (M.R. Farrally and A.J. Cochran, eds., Human Kinetics,                                  
                 undated) (Farrally).1                                                                               

                                                                                                                    
                 1 There is no dispute as to whether Farrally is prior art.                                          

                                                         2                                                           

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013