Ex Parte Brennan - Page 4



               Appeal 2006-2708                                                                            
               Application 09/824,454                                                                      

                      Since claims 3-5 are dependent upon claim 1 and include all the                      
               limitations therein, it follows that the Examiner’s § 103 rejection of claims               
               3-5 must fall as well.                                                                      
                      In conclusion, based on the foregoing, we are constrained to reverse                 
               the Examiner’s rejections.                                                                  
                                               REVERSED                                                    


               clj                                                                                         
               The Procter & Gamble Company                                                                
               Intellectual Property Division - West Bldg.                                                 
               Winton Hill Business Center - Box 412                                                       
               6250 Center Hill Ave.                                                                       
               Cincinnati, OH  45224                                                                       














                                                    4                                                      



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4

Last modified: September 9, 2013