Ex Parte Yu et al - Page 5

               Appeal 2006-2924                                                                             
               Application 10/668,522                                                                       
               the greeting card being removed from contact with the lower writeable                        
               surface (Specification 6:7-19).  Appellants’ UV LED illuminates the indicia                  
               on the greeting card visible only under UV light (Specification 3-4).  As                    
               illustrated in Figs. 1 and 5B, this might encompass the entire width of the                  
               card or substrate, indicating Appellants’ characterization of UV LEDs as                     
               capable of relatively broad angle illumination.                                              
               FF3. Solomon discloses a writing system, applicable to all forms of writing                  
               and drawing, and to diaries, journals, stationery, and games in particular,                  
               with the intention of guarding the handwritten or drawn content using a                      
               combination of special ink visible to the human eye only upon excitation by                  
               ultraviolet light (ultraviolet ink), paper, and ultraviolet light (Solomon,                  
               [0001], [0015], and [0017]).  Solomon’s invention is intended to be an                       
               improvement over prior art diaries or journals with simple padlock and                       
               combination lock devices, whose very existence may invite unwanted                           
               intrusion (Solomon, [0002]).                                                                 
               FF4. Solomon’s detailed disclosure is directed to the preferred embodiment                   
               of a bound book, such as a diary or journal (Solomon, [0012] – [0020]).                      
               Solomon does not describe in detail an embodiment of the invention directed                  
               to stationery, other than to mention that correspondence may be written                      
               using the ultraviolet ink and that the recipient would be able to read the                   
               correspondence only through the use of an ultraviolet light (Solomon,                        
               [0021]).                                                                                     
               FF5. Solomon discloses an ultraviolet light bulb 11, which bulb is                           
               cylindrical in the preferred embodiment, with the light being emitted in a                   
               direction away from the axis of the cylindrical light bulb, allowing for a                   
               broad angle of emitted ultraviolet light of uniform intensity for ease of                    

                                                     5                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013