Ex Parte Spotnitz et al - Page 2


              Appeal 2006-3087                                                                      
              Application 09/821,553                                                                

                                           INVENTION                                                
                    The invention is directed to a system for designing charge storage              
              devices (e.g. a battery).  See pages 1 and 2 of Appellants’ specification.            
              Claim 1 is representative of the invention and reproduced below:                      
                          A method for charge storage device (CSD) customer driven                  
                    charge storage device design comprising the steps of:                           
                          providing more than one model of a charge storage device, the             
                    model adapted to convert at least one CSD customer inputted                     
                    requirement selected from the group consisting of energy density,               
                    cycle life, rate capability, impedance, temperature range of operation          
                    and/or survival, safety requirements, storage life, self-discharge              
                    behavior, form factor, and cost into at least one CSD design;                   
                          providing an interface, the interface being adapted to pass the           
                    CSD customer inputted requirement to the model, the interface being             
                    adapted to pass CSD design from the model, and the interface being              
                    adapted to hide the model;                                                      
                          wherein the CSD customer addresses the interface with the                 
                    CSD customer inputted requirement, the interface directs the CSD                
                    customer inputted requirement to at least one of the models, the model          
                    generates the CSD design that passes through the interface to the CSD           
                    customer.                                                                       
                                          REFERENCES                                                
                    The reference relied upon by the Examiner is:                                   
                    Notten  US 6,016,047  Jan. 18, 2000                                             
                                      REJECTIONS AT ISSUE                                           
                    Claims 1 through 5 and 7 through 12 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C.              
              § 103(a) as being unpatentable over Notten.  The Examiner’s rejection is set          
              forth on pages 3 through 7 of the Answer.  Throughout the opinion we make             


                                                 2                                                  

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013