Ex Parte Trajkovic et al - Page 3



                Appeal 2007-0145                                                                              
                Application 10/183,797                                                                        

                                               DISCUSSION                                                     
                Claim interpretation                                                                          
                      We interpret a "window" to be a viewing area on a screen that                           
                contains an application or part of an application.  Windows can be displayed                  
                to take up the full screen or tiled as in Appellants' Figure 3.  A "window"                   
                environment requires an operating system (OS), such as Microsoft Windows                      
                OS or the Apple MacIntosh OS, to provide for multiple windows; however,                       
                the term "window" does not imply Microsoft Windows.  Only one window                          
                at a time is "active" (i.e., being worked in).  We find that ordinary computer                
                users were familiar with windows in, at least, the Microsoft Windows OS                       
                environment at the time that this application was filed (in 2002).                            
                      A "protected window" refers to an active window that is to be                           
                inactivated after a predetermined period of time in which there is no detected                
                activity (Specification ¶ 0032).  Although the Specification discloses that a                 
                window may be protected because it displays secret or sensitive information,                  
                this is not claimed.  The claims do not require that the "protected window" is                
                one of plural windows displayed on the monitor screen.                                        
                      The limitation "inactivating the protected window" means that an                        
                "active" window (i.e., one that is being worked in) is made "inactive."                       
                Although the Specification describes that "inactivating" involves concealing                  
                the contents of the protected window in some manner, such as by                               
                minimizing the protected window, closing the protected window, or                             
                changing the protected window to a default window (Specification ¶ 0014),                     
                                                      3                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013