Ex Parte Kelly et al - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-0291                                                                                
                Application 09/976,412                                                                          

                       According to Appellants, the invention is directed to a low                              
                contaminant wiper suitable for use in a cleanroom environment, where the                        
                wiper is made from low contaminant polyester filaments substantially free of                    
                inorganic ionic additives with a discontinuous fused border zone along one                      
                or more perimeter edges (Br. 3).  Independent claim 5 is illustrative of the                    
                invention and is reproduced below:                                                              
                       5.  A low contaminant wiper suitable for use in a cleanroom                              
                environment and being constructed of a low contaminant textile fabric                           
                having a machine direction and a cross-machine direction, said fabric being                     
                formed from a multiplicity of yarns made of polyester filaments, the low                        
                contaminant wiper comprising: an interior and a plurality of perimeter edges                    
                disposed in surrounding relation to the interior and at least one discontinuous                 
                fused border zone disposed inboard of and extending substantially parallel to                   
                at least two of the perimeter edges, wherein each of said discontinuous fused                   
                border zones comprises a plurality of substantially discrete fusion points                      
                formed by localized melt fusion of said thermoplastic filaments such that                       
                said discrete fusion points are disposed within a matrix of unmelted material,                  
                and wherein said polyester filaments are substantially free of inorganic ionic                  
                additives, such that complete combustion of said polyester filaments yields                     
                an ash content of not greater than about 0.1% of the initial weight of said                     
                polyester filaments.                                                                            

                       The Examiner has relied on the following references as evidence of                       
                obviousness:                                                                                    
                Paley                                          US 4,888,229                          Dec. 19, 1989
                Langley                                      US 4,938,817                          Jul. 03, 1990
                Rockwell                                    US 6,001,442                          Dec. 14, 1999 
                Dean                                           US 6,139,954                          Oct. 31, 2000
                Morin                                          US 6,189,189 B1                    Feb. 20, 2001 





                                                       2                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013