Ex Parte Dunman - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-0293                                                                                
                Application 10/630,982                                                                          

                       According to Appellant, the invention is directed to a method of                         
                protecting portions of containers from being coated while other portions of                     
                the containers are coated (Br. 7).  The method includes the steps of making                     
                the containers from a first material, coating the containers with a second                      
                material, and, prior to coating, covering the portions of the container that                    
                should remain uncoated with shields of the first material, where the shields                    
                are made from scraps of the first material used to make the container (id.).                    
                Claim 1 is illustrative of the invention and is reproduced below:                               
                             1. A method of protecting portions of containers from being                        
                       coated while other portions of the containers are being coated,                          
                       comprising:                                                                              
                             making containers from a first material;                                           
                             coating the containers with a second material; and                                 
                             prior to coating, covering portions of the containers to remain                    
                       uncoated with shields of the first material,                                             
                             wherein the shields are made from scraps of the first material                     
                       produced from the making of the containers.                                              
                       In addition to Appellant’s admitted prior art (hereafter APA), the                       
                Examiner relies on the following references as evidence of obviousness:                         
                Carl                                         US 3,740,259                         Jun. 19, 1973 
                White                                      US 4,667,620                         May 26, 1987    







                                                       2                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013