Ex Parte Waller et al - Page 3

                Appeal 2007-0320                                                                                 
                Application 09/945,339                                                                           

                       According to the present Specification,                                                   
                       • “[t]he mononuclear cells are incubated with a sufficient                                
                             concentration of [a] cytotoxic drug so as to substantially reduce                   
                             their ability to cause graft versus host disease while they retain                  
                             their ability to proliferate in the recipient to enhance the                        
                             recipient’s ability to fight cancer, leukemia and viral infection”                  
                             (Spec. 19: 11-15, emphasis added);                                                  
                       • “[a] ‘sufficient concentration’ [of the cytotoxic drug] is that                         
                             which causes greater than 90% inhibition of the proliferation of                    
                             treated cells as measured by assays known in the art” (Spec. 19:                    
                             15-17);                                                                             
                       • “the phrase ‘substantially reduce their ability to cause graft                          
                             versus host disease’ means that as a result of treatment                            
                             according to the methods of the invention, a given                                  
                             concentration of treated mononuclear cells administered to a                        
                             recipient results in the absence of graft versus host disease,                      
                             whereas the same concentration of untreated mononuclear cells                       
                             administered to a recipient results in severe graft versus host                     
                             disease” (Spec. 15: 24 to 16: 2); and                                               
                       • “[b]y ‘proliferation’ is meant cell division that leads to an                           
                             increase in the number of nucleated cells such that the number                      
                             of cells and their progeny at, for example, time T + 1 is greater                   
                             than the number of cells at time T” (Spec. 16: 11-13).                              
                       • Finally, “[b]y ‘in combination’ is meant the treated                                    
                             mononuclear cells can be administered to the recipient before,                      
                             contemporaneously with, or after the administration of the                          
                             hematopoietic cells to the recipient” (Spec. 15: 21-24).                            

                       Thus, based on the explicit teachings of the Specification, claim 1                       
                requires that the treated mononuclear cells retain their ability to proliferate,                 



                                                       3                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013