Ex Parte 6394644 et al - Page 6

                 Appeal  2007-0380                                                                                  
                 Reexamination Control  90/007,199                                                                  
                 Patent 6,394,644 B1                                                                                
                       between bars 4 and produce, in each mixing plate 2, shaped angled                            
                       cavities 6, which are designed in such a way that one transverse rib 5                       
                       is produced between them on the surface on one side of the mixing                            
                       plate 2….”  (Duke 3-4).                                                                      
                    15. Duke further states that “[a]t least two adjacent mixing plates 2 are                       
                       always superimposed on one another in such a way that the adjacent                           
                       shaped angled cavities 6 produced in one mixing plate 2 form,                                
                       together with the shaped angled cavities 6 in the adjacent mixing plate                      
                       2, transverse prismatic cavities 10 permitting the flow-through of the                       
                       molten material ….”  (Duke 4).                                                               
                                                        Signer                                                      
                    16. Signer teaches a device comprising static mixing elements.                                  
                    17. As noted by the Examiner, in the device taught by Signer, not all of                        
                       the crossbars are laterally connected directly to an adjacent crossbar at                    
                       the respective ends of the crossbars.  (Answer 16).                                          
                    18. Streiff claim 25 does not require direct connection of adjacent                             
                       crossbars but does require “a mixing structure located in said flow                          
                       path between said edge surfaces and including a plurality of mixer                           
                       components, each of said mixer components having a first end located                         
                       between said edges surfaces…and a second end located between said                            
                       edge surfaces” where the mixer components comprise crossbars.                                
                    19. The crossbars of Signer extend beyond the edge surfaces.  (See, e.g.,                       
                       Fig. 4).                                                                                     
                                                 Written Description                                                
                    20. Claim 23 requires that the circumferentially extended surface that                          
                       extends perpendicularly relative to the axis extends perpendicularly                         

                                                         6                                                          

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013