Ex Parte Kreulen et al - Page 7



           Appeal No. 2007-0429                                                                      
           Application 09/848,430                                                                    

           therefore correct to characterize Call as developing an “uninterrupted array of           
           integers corresponding to an occurrence of terms” (Answer), a characterization that       
           reflects the language employed in claim 5.6  The Examiner did not find that Call          
           discloses or suggests using the disclosed method to develop an array of integers          
           that represents a plurality of documents.                                                 
                 As evidence that it would have been obvious to use Call’s method to                 
           generate a listing of integers representing a document corpus that contains an            
           ordered plurality of documents, the Examiner relies on Pirolli.  Pirolli discloses a      
           system for analyzing the topology, content, and usage of collections of linked            
           documents such as those found on the World Wide Web (hereinafter, Web) in                 
           order to facilitate information searching or improving the design of a web locality       
           (col. 1, l. 65 to col. 2, l. 1).  A web locality is as “[a] collection of related web     
           pages associated with an entity having a site on the World-Wide Web such as a             
           company, educational institute or the like” (col. 3, ll. 41-43).  Pirolli’s system        
           provides (a) categorization based on “feature vectors” that characterize individual       
           page information and (b) prediction of the need for (or relevance of) other Web           
           pages with respect to a particular context, which could be a particular page or set of    
                                                                                                    
                 6   Claim 5, for example, reads:                                                    
                       5.  A method of converting, organizing, and representing in a                 
                 computer memory a document corpus containing an ordered plurality                   
                 of documents, said method comprising:                                               
                       for said document corpus, taking in sequence each said ordered                
                 document and developing a first uninterrupted listing of integers to                
                 correspond to an occurrence of terms in the document corpus.                        
                                                  7                                                  



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013