Ex Parte Shwarts et al - Page 6



                   Appeal 2007-0493                                                                                                 
                   Application 10/289,967                                                                                           
                   Patent 6,144,380                                                                                                 

                                                  III. FINDINGS OF FACT                                                             
                           The following findings of fact (FF) are supported by a preponderance                                     
                   of the evidence.                                                                                                 
                                        A.  The Invention of U.S. Patent 6,144,380                                                  
                           1.     According to Appellants, they invented (U.S. Patent 6,144,380,                                    
                   Abstract 1-10):                                                                                                  
                                          A method for controlling a screen display of an                                           
                                  electronic book. The contents of the book are displayed                                           
                                  on a screen of the computer system as pages with which                                            
                                  the user interacts by a pointer such as a pen or stylus. The                                      
                                  content engine performs various functions including one                                           
                                  or more of the following: (1) creating page displays for                                          
                                  content of the book, (2) providing a navigation interface                                         
                                  for identifying material in the book and moving to                                                
                                  desired locations, (3) finding character strings located                                          
                                  within the book, and (4) accepting handwritten                                                    
                                  information on pages of the book.                                                                 
                           2.     The invention claimed in U.S. Patent 6,144,380, is directed to                                    
                   function “(4) accepting handwritten information on pages of the book” as                                         
                   shown in the claim step of “displaying handwriting written on the current                                        
                   page of the book after a mark-up button has been selected” (Patent claim 1).3                                    



                                                                                                                                    
                   3  Claim 19 as originally filed in each of Applications 08/147,142, and                                          
                   08/454,061 and 08/801,251 which are the grandparent application, parent                                          
                   application, and original application, respectively, of U.S. Patent 6,144,380                                    
                   for which reissue is sought.                                                                                     
                                                               - 6 -                                                                

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013