Ex Parte Caudill et al - Page 4


                Appeal 2007-1112                                                                             
                Application 10/692,116                                                                       


                      8. Claim 3, below and which depends from claim 2, also below, is                       
                         representative of claims 3-5 and 10-13 rejected over the                            
                         combination of Haldenby, Seal, and Luttmann.                                        
                            2.     The gas cylinder of Claim 1, wherein said plastic coating                 
                      is heat bonded to said inner side.                                                     
                            3.     The gas cylinder of Claim 2, wherein said plastic coating                 
                      is a polyethylene copolymer.                                                           
                      9. Haldenby teaches metal, and particularly steel, cylinders for                       
                         containing gases and liquids wherein a uniform, relatively thick                    
                         layer of a polymeric material is applied to the interior surface of                 
                         the cylinders such that none of the gas or liquid comes into contact                
                         with the metal.  (Haldenby at 5-15 and 49-61).                                      
                      10.  Preferred coating materials are said to be polyolefins such as                    
                         polyethylene.  (Haldenby at 2:41-46).                                               
                      11.  Haldenby further notes that “[i]t is known to coat the interior of                
                         metal cylinders with a plastic coating to prevent attack by reactive                
                         gases.”  (Haldenby at 22-25).                                                       
                      12.  In discussing the background of its invention, Seal states that                   
                         “there are basically two primary technologies” used for                             
                         “lightweight, high-pressure gas containment” one of which is                        
                         “graphite/epoxy composite with a yielding aluminum liner.”  (Seal                   
                         at 1:39-41).                                                                        




                                                     4                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013