Ex Parte Dutta et al - Page 4

              Appeal 2007-1651                                                                     
              Application 09/791,152                                                               
              (King, col. 41, line 7), which is equivalent to the spacing proximity policy of      
              the claimed invention.”                                                              
                    Thus, the issue before us is whether King teaches or makes obvious             
              determining whether a page falls within a proximity policy and reformatting          
              the page to fall within the proximity policy wherein the proximity policy            
              defines a minimal spacing between respective links within a page.                    

                                           FINDINGS OF FACT                                        
                    1. King teaches a system to create documents where the same                    
                            content elements can be put into different document formats.           
                            Col. 6, ll. 20-36.                                                     
                    2. King teaches that the data may contain indications of the                   
                            amount of space to be allocated to elements.  Col. 30, ll. 26-         
                            39, figures 28A-28D, and col. 32 ll. 30-55.                            
                    3. King teaches that when the content elements of the document                 
                            do not fit within the space of the template, the content size is       
                            adjusted to fit the space in the template. Col. 40, ll. 43-54.         
                    4. The adjustment of content is achieved through a scale factor,               
                            which may be different for different types of content, e.g. the        
                            scale factor for text may be different than for photos.  Col.          
                            40, ll. 55-67.                                                         
                    5. One of the scale factors is the “white space scale factor” but              
                            no definition of this scaling factor is identified.  Col. 41, l. 7.    





                                                4                                                  


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013