Ex Parte Shimazaki et al - Page 3

                Appeal 2007-1676                                                                                
                Application 10/439,183                                                                          
                11.  A golf club head comprising:                                                               
                       a metal head body defining a hollow portion and an opening portion;                      
                       and                                                                                      
                       a metal piece including tungsten alloy,                                                  
                       wherein the metal piece is joined to the opening portion by arc-                         
                       welding the metal piece to the opening portion, and                                      
                       wherein the metal head body is made of stainless steel, and                              
                       wherein the metal piece includes the following compositions based on                     
                       the total weight of the metal piece:                                                     
                       tungsten in a range of 28wt% - 32wt%;                                                    
                       iron in a range of 45wt% - 49wt%;                                                        
                       nickel in a range of 15wt% - 17wt%; and                                                  
                       copper in a range of lwt% - 3wt%; and                                                    
                       wherein the sum of amount of tungsten, iron, nickel, and copper in the                   
                       metal piece is in a range of 93wt% to 98wt%.                                             

                       The Examiner relies on the following prior art references to show                        
                unpatentability:                                                                                
                       Shira   US 5,669,825   Sep. 23, 1997                                                     
                       Nakahara  US 5,967,905   Oct. 19, 1999                                                   
                       Nishizawa  US 6,012,990   Jan. 11, 2000                                                  
                       Lee   US 6,319,149 B1   Nov. 20, 2001                                                    





                                                       3                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013