Ex Parte Klesczewski et al - Page 2

               Appeal 2007-1905                                                                          
               Reissue Application 10/931,249                                                            
               Patent 6,444,720 B1                                                                       
           1         We have jurisdiction under 35 U.S.C. § 6(b).                                        
           2         The reissue application on appeal was filed on 31 August 2004.                      
           3         The reissue application seeks to reissue Patent 6,444,720 B1, issued                
           4   03 September 2002, based on application 09/959,253, filed 11 April 2000.                  
           5         The real party in interest is Bayer Aktiengesellchaft.                              
           6         Appellants [hereafter "Bayer"] claim benefit of an earlier filing date              
           7   based on (1) PCT/EP00/03218, filed 11 April 2000, and (2) German patent                   
           8   application 199 18 726, filed 24 April 1999.                                              
           9         The Examiner rejected claims 1-14 (all of the claims) under 35 U.S.C.               
         10    § 103(a) as being unpatentable over Okada, Heuvelsland and Coe.  (The                     
         11    reader should know that no references to et al. are made in this opinion.)                
         12          The following prior art was relied upon by the Examiner.                            
         13                                                                                              
         14          Name                 Patent Number                 Issue Date                       
         15    Heuvelsland              US 5,010,187            23 Apr. 1991                             
         16    Coe                      US 5,177,117            05 Jan. 1993                             
         17         Okada              EP 0,622,388 A1         02 Nov. 1994                             
         18                                                                                              
         19          Okada, Heuvelsland, and Coe are prior art under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b).                 
         20                                                                                              
         21          B.  Record on appeal                                                                
         22          In deciding this appeal, we have considered only the following                      
         23    documents:                                                                                
         24                1.    Reissue specification, including original claims.                       
         25                2.    Final Rejection entered 27 April 2006.                                  



                                                   2                                                     

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013