Ex Parte Gass et al - Page 2

                Appeal  2007-2769                                                                             
                Application 09/929,242                                                                        

                contact between a person and a cutting tool, and a reaction system which                      
                retracts the cutting tool away from the cutting region and stops the rotation                 
                of the blade.                                                                                 
                      Claim 1, reproduced below, is further illustrative of the claimed                       
                subject matter.1                                                                              

                      1.  A woodworking machine having a cutting region for                                   
                      cutting workpieces, comprising:                                                         
                             a movable cutting tool for cutting workpieces in the                             
                      cutting region;                                                                         
                             a detection system adapted to detect contact between a                           
                      person and the cutting tool; and                                                        
                             a reaction system associated with the detection system                           
                      and the cutting tool, where the reaction system is configured to                        
                      retract the cutting tool at least partially away from the cutting                       
                      region upon detection of contact by the detection system.                               
                             The references of record relied upon by the Examiner as                          
                      evidence of obviousness are:                                                            

                Friemann    US 3,858,095  Dec. 31, 1974                                                       
                Terauchi     US 4,512,224  Apr. 23, 1985                                                      
                Hauer  (as translated)  DE 196 09 771 A1  Jun.  04, 1998                                      




                                                                                                             
                1 It is noted that “the rotation” and “the blade” of claim 5 have not been                    
                previously recited and lack clear antecedent basis from claim 1.                              
                                                      2                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013