Ex Parte Tian et al - Page 2

           Appeal 2007-3374                                                      
           Application 10/448,758                                                

                             STATEMENT OF THE CASE                               
                The subject matter on appeal is directed to surface coverings, such as
           floor coverings and wallpaper, “having difference in gloss in selected
           regions or zones . . . ” (Specification 1, para. 001).  Further details of the
           appealed subject matter are recited in representative claim 1 reproduced
           below:                                                                

                1.  A surface covering comprising:                               
                a) a surface covering substrate having a top surface and a       
                bottom surface,                                                  
                b) a primer overlying a portion of the top surface of the        
                surface covering substrate, wherein the primer comprises a       
                flatting agent, and                                              
                c) a top coat overlying at least a portion of the primer and     
                overlying substantially all of the top surface of the surface    
                covering substrate,                                              
                wherein the top coat overlying the primer has a gloss level      
                less than the gloss of the top coat not overlying the primer.    
                The Examiner has relied upon the following references:           
           Carder        US 3,966,572        Jun. 29, 1976                       
           Mawson        US 4,172,169        Oct. 23, 1979                       
           Schneider        US 4,207,368        Jun. 10, 1980                    
           Sigel ‘501        US 2002/0168501 A1       Nov. 14, 2002              
           MacQueen        US 6,759,096 B2       Jul. 6, 2004                    
           Sigel ‘625        US 6,890,625 B2       May 10, 2005                  





                                        2                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013