Ex Parte Eckel et al - Page 5

               Appeal 2007-4316                                                                            
               Application 09/911,268                                                                      
               processes such as chromatography or solvent extraction.  (268 Application                   
               at 22:1–5.)                                                                                 
               7. A particular example of an oligophosphate is shown in formula (V), in                    
               which R1, R2, R3 and R4 are all phenyl, n and q are 0, and N, the                           
               oligomerization index, is 1.1.  (Y, isopropyldene, is -C(CH3)2-).                           
               (268 Application at 27:10–19.)                                                              
               8. The inventors provide in Table 2 a comparison of the physical                            
               properties of a sample of polycarbonate containing an oligophosphate having                 
               9 wt% IPP with an otherwise identical polycarbonate containing an                           
               oligophosphate having 0.1 wt% IPP.  (268 Application at 30.)                                
               9. The properties are said to have been determined according to various                     
               standards listed in the 268 Application at 29.                                              
               10. According to Table 2, the polycarbonate sample having less IPP has a                    
               higher notched impact strength, higher heat resistance, higher flame                        
               resistance, and exhibits less yellowing upon aging.  (268 Application at 30.)               
                      Eckel 930                                                                            
               11. Eckel 930 describes flame resistant polycarbonate molding                               
               compositions.  (Eckel 930 at 2:26–3:11.)                                                    
               12. The Eckel 930 compositions comprise, inter alia, component D that is                    
               an oligophosphate comparable to the oligophosphates described in the                        
               268 Application, but for the limitation on the amount of IPP (Id. at  8:1–54).              
               13. In particular, Eckel 930 oligophosphate D.1 is within the scope of                      
               formula (I) of the 268 Application, and is nearly the same as the                           
               oligophosphate of formula (V) used in the example of the 268 application                    

                                                   5                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013