Leo N. Levitt and Ruth G. Levitt - Page 66

                                       - 66 -                                         
          benefit for purposes of deciding whether denial of innocent                 
          spouse relief is inequitable under section 6013(e)(1)(D).                   
          Flynn v. Commissioner, 93 T.C. 355, 367 (1989).                             
               Petitioners contend that Ruth Levitt did not significantly             
          benefit from the unreported income.  We disagree.  The statute              
          by its terms no longer bars relief if the purported innocent                
          spouse received a significant benefit, but it continues to be               
          a factor.  Estate of Krock v. Commissioner, 93 T.C. 672, 678                
          (1989).  The benefit may be direct or indirect.  Id. at 678.                
          Ruth Levitt enjoyed the benefits of the understatements during              
          the years in issue.  She drove new cars, had a nursemaid, sent              
          her children to camp, and lived materially well.  She had the               
          services of a chauffeur and handyman.  Some of her children                 
          attended private schools.  She shopped extensively.  Resyn                  
          paid about $1,035,106 for those personal expenses of petitioners            
          from 1967 to 1969.  She benefited from petitioners' tax                     
          deductions for charitable contributions that Resyn paid in                  
          1967 and 1968.  Resyn also paid for petitioners to buy Welev                
          stock that Ruth Levitt sold in 1986, reporting a capital gain               
          of $999,338.  There is no indication that Ruth Levitt's                     
          benefit from unreported income was any different from 1964 to               
          1966.  We believe that petitioners' unreported income allowed               
          her to have the standard of living that she did during the                  




Page:  Previous  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011