Elaine S. Bennett - Page 5

                                        - 5 -                                         

          Transfer Refund on account of transferring from the Retirement              
          System to the Pension System, petitioner's monthly annuity will             
          be less than the monthly annuity she would have received if she             
          had not transferred to the Pension System but had retired under             
          the Retirement System.6                                                     
               C.  Petitioner's Federal Income Tax Return                             
               Petitioner did not attempt to roll over the taxable portion            
          of the Transfer Refund.  See sec. 402(a)(5).  Rather, on her                
          Federal income tax return (Form 1040) for 1991, petitioner                  
          reported such portion of the Transfer Refund as ordinary income.7           
          Further, in computing her income tax liability for 1991,                    
          petitioner did not attempt to income average pursuant to section            
          402(e)(1); rather, she computed such liability by reference to              
          the tax rate schedule applicable to her filing status.                      
               In the notice of deficiency, respondent characterized the              
          taxable portion of petitioner's reported retirement distributions           


          6         It should be recalled that petitioner remained employed           
          by the State of Maryland at the time that this case was submitted           
          to the Court in July 1996.                                                  
          7         Petitioner also reported on her return another                    
          retirement distribution in the gross (and taxable) amount of                
          $158.  Accordingly, petitioner reported total retirement                    
          distributions in the gross amount of $348,641 (i.e., $348,483 +             
          $158) and in the taxable amount of $327,814 (i.e., $327,656 +               
          $158).  The parties have stipulated that the $158 distribution,             
          as well as the Transfer Refund (in the amount of $348,483), was             
          received from the Retirement System.  However, the record does              
          not disclose the relationship of the $158 distribution to the               
          Transfer Refund.  See infra note 8 and the accompanying text.               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011