Elaine S. Bennett - Page 9

                                        - 9 -                                         

          her position or occupation and is still employed."                          
               We accept as a fact that the Transfer Refund was not paid to           
          petitioner on account of her retirement but rather as an                    
          inducement for her to transfer from the Retirement System to the            
          Pension System.  We also accept as a fact that petitioner has not           
          retired and is still employed.  However, we reject petitioner's             
          argument that the Transfer Refund did not constitute a retirement           
          distribution within the meaning of section 4980A.                           
               The fatal flaw in petitioner's argument is that the term               
          "retirement distribution" is statutorily defined.  Thus,                    
          petitioner's reliance on Webster's Dictionary definition of                 
          "retirement", as a "withdrawal from one's position or                       
          occupation", is to no avail.  Our analysis is necessarily                   
          governed by the meaning of the operative term as it is                      
          specifically defined by Congress and not as it may be more                  
          popularly construed.  2A Singer, Sutherland Statutory                       
          Construction sec. 47.07, at 151, (5th ed. 1992).                            
               As we have already discussed, section 4980A(e)(1)(A) defines           
          the term "retirement distribution" to mean the amount distributed           
          during the taxable year under a qualified employer plan with                
          respect to which the individual is or was the employee.                     
          Petitioner's Transfer Refund fits squarely within this                      
          definition.  Indeed, petitioner admits that she "received a                 
          distribution [the Transfer Refund] from her qualified plan [the             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011