Donald L. Chiappetti and Mary K. Chiappetti - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         

          executed the purchase contract on behalf of CPC as its president,           
          at the insistence of the buyer Donald C. Chiappetti, petitioner             
          Donald L. Chiappetti executed the covenant not to compete in his            
          individual capacity.                                                        
               Other provisions in the purchase contract also undermine               
          petitioners' principal position herein.  Thus, the purchase                 
          contract provided in section 17 that if the option to repurchase            
          the items described in section 1 thereof were exercised, "Donald            
          L. Chiappetti shall no longer be subject to the Covenant Not to             
          Compete".5  Neither the covenant not to compete nor any other               
          provision in the purchase contract provided that CPC would be re-           
          leased from the covenant not to compete in the event that CPC               
          were to exercise the option to repurchase.                                  
               It is also significant that exhibit A attached to the                  
          purchase contract that allocated the $125,000 purchase price that           
          Donald C. Chiappetti was to pay for the items he was acquiring              


          5  We acknowledge that the following phrase contained in the                
          option to repurchase may at first blush appear to be confusing:             
          "Seller, not being entirely sure that he wants to retire from the           
          practice of dentistry, shall have the option of repurchasing the            
          assets described in Section 1".  We have found that the phrase              
          "not being entirely sure that he wants to retire" (emphasis                 
          added) is a reference to petitioner in his individual capacity.             
          However, the option to repurchase provides that the seller, i.e.,           
          CPC (not petitioner), was entitled to repurchase the assets sold            
          pursuant to that contract, including the covenant not to compete.           
          In any event, what is significant to us in resolving the issue              
          herein is that the option to repurchase specifically and unambig-           
          uously releases petitioner, and not CPC, from the covenant not to           
          compete in the event that that option were exercised.                       




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011