The Board of Trade of the City of Chicago and Subsidiaries - Page 7

                                        - 7 -                                         

          transferee, in accordance with petitioner’s rule 243,1 must pay a           
          transfer fee.                                                               
               Petitioner's rule 243 is separated into three sentences.               
          The first states that “No transfer of a membership may be                   
          consummated unless the transferee pays to the Association a                 
          transfer fee”.2  The transfer fee applies not only to sales of              
          memberships but also to transfers of memberships without                    
          consideration, such as intrafamily transfers and intrafirm                  
          transfers from the name of an owner firm’s qualified partner or             
          employee to another qualified individual in the firm.                       
          Petitioner’s management regards the transfer fees as necessary              
          for applicants to understand and recognize that they are the                
          owners of the association.                                                  
               The second sentence of rule 243 states that “The amount of             
          [the transfer fee] is established from time to time by the Board            
          of Directors.”3  The amount of the transfer fee depends on the              
          class of membership transferred.  During the taxable years 1988             
          through 1990, the transfer fees set by petitioner's board of                

          1  Rule 243 is part of the bylaws of the CBOT, adopted and                  
          amended by the owners of CBOT memberships.                                  
          2  In 1925, the CBOT members adopted the predecessor of rule                
          243, then known as rule 111.  Rule 111 was amended in 1937 to               
          specify that the purchaser of a membership would pay the transfer           
          fee.  Prior thereto, rule 111 specified that the seller would pay           
          the fee.                                                                    
          3  In 1970, rule 111 was amended to provide that the amount                 
          of the transfer fee would be set by the board of directors.                 




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011