Estate of Joseph R. Cloutier, Joseph A. Cloutier, Fiduciary - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         
          exclusively on the hypothetical buyer, to the exclusion of the              
          hypothetical seller.  In this latter regard, we find unpersuasive           
          Mr. Alerding’s conclusion that a willing seller of a 100-percent            
          interest in CGT would have to discount the value of that interest           
          by 25 percent for lack of marketability.  See Mandelbaum v.                 
          Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1995-255; Moore v. Commissioner,                   
          T.C. Memo. 1991-546.                                                        
               We also note that Mr. Alerding has limited experience with             
          respect to the valuation at hand.  In response to questions from            
          the Court, Mr. Alerding acknowledged that he had no experience in           
          valuing television station property, and that he had reached his            
          conclusion without direct reference to similar publicly traded              
          property or stock.  Although a marketability discount may apply             
          in some cases where 100 percent of the stock of an unlisted                 
          corporation is held by one shareholder, a discount for lack of              
          marketability is inapplicable when the value of the unlisted                
          stock is not determined by reference to the price of listed                 
          stock.5  This is a key point that Mr. Alerding missed when he               

          4 (...continued)                                                            
          88 T.C. 1577, 1589 (1987); Estate of Trenchard v. Commissioner,             
          supra; accord Rev. Rul. 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237, 242 (controlling            
          interest in closely held company may command a higher price than            
          a minority interest).                                                       
          5 As we understand the thrust of Mr. Alerding’s thinking                    
          with respect to marketability discounts, the value of a single              
          asset is significantly reduced by a lack of marketability                   
                                                             (continued...)           






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011