Harold E. Emmons and Anna Mae Emmons - Page 16

                                       - 16 -                                         
          the 5 years preceding the Transfer Refund election.  Md. Ann.               
          Code, art. 73B, sec. 11B(5)(b) (1988).  The rate of earnings was            
          then applied retroactively, starting from petitioner's date of              
          employment, and was compounded annually as if such rate had been            
          actually earned during each year of service by petitioner.  Thus,           
          the rate of earnings utilized in computing the amount of the                
          Transfer Refund had no relationship to the actual earnings of               
          petitioner's contributions, and therefore cannot be considered a            
          benefit based in part on the separate account of petitioner under           
          section 414(k).                                                             
               Second, we reject petitioners' contention because the                  
          existence of a separate account under section 414(k) is                     
          irrelevant for purposes of determining "the balance to the credit           
          of an employee" under section 402(e)(4)(A).  Section 414(k)                 
          provides that a defined benefit plan with a defined contribution            
          component will be treated, in part, as a defined contribution               
          plan for purposes of sections 410, 72(d), 411(a)(7)(A), 415, and            
          401(m).  We note that section 414(k) does not specify section               
          402(e)(4)(C) as one of the sections for purposes of which a                 
          defined benefit plan will be treated as a defined contribution              
          plan.  Therefore, even if petitioner's mandatory contributions              
          constituted a separate account under section 414(k), this fact              
          would have no effect in determining petitioner's balance to the             
          credit.  See Green v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1994-340, wherein            






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011