Hospital Corporation of America and Subsidiaries - Page 46

                                       - 46 -                                         
               Medical supplies play a necessary and vital role in the                
          diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of the hospitals' patients.             
          In many cases, medical services can not be rendered without using           
          medical supplies.  The furnishing of medical supplies by the                
          hospitals is merely incidental to the main purpose of rendering             
          health care services that a patient seeks when entering a                   
          hospital.  The hospitals do not acquire medical supplies for sale           
          to patients but rather to render medical services.  Moreover,               
          under current payment arrangements between the hospitals and                
          public and private insurers, the hospitals' bills to patients               
          generally bear no particular relationship to the amounts that the           
          hospitals actually will be paid for the services provided.                  
               Patients, furthermore, do not come to the hospitals to buy             
          medical supplies; rather, they are there primarily to obtain a              
          course of treatment.  In many cases patients are not even aware             
          of all of the medical supplies that are used in the course of the           
          medical treatment.  Patients generally are concerned with the               
          treatment and healing processes and not with the medical supplies           
          utilized by the hospitals in rendering medical treatment.                   


          18  (...continued)                                                          
          Regs.  Our conclusion here does not change the result in our                
          prior Memorandum Opinion, given that for the years ended 1981               
          through 1986 petitioners' hospitals employed a hybrid method of             
          accounting, not the cash method or an accrual method.  Our                  
          holding applies equally to any accounts receivable attributable             
          to medical supplies that are dispensed to employees or dependents           
          of employees for their personal use.                                        





Page:  Previous  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011