Schmidt Baking Company, Inc. - Page 15

                                           - 15 -                                            
          in this case is particularly appropriate where neither party                       
          questions the validity of the 2-1/2 month rule, but merely its                     
          application.                                                                       
                Prior to 1987, section 404(a)(5) contained only the first                    
          sentence; the rules governing vacation pay were contained in                       
          section 463, which provided for a deduction based on the                           
          establishment of a reserve.  In 1987, when the Omnibus Budget                      
          Reconciliation Act of 1987, Pub. L. 100-203, 101 Stat. 1330, was                   
          being considered, both the House and Senate proposed to repeal                     
          section 463 and make no change in section 404(a)(5) as it then                     
          stood.  In so doing, the House Ways and Means Committee and the                    
          Senate Finance Committee discussed the proposed action in the                      
          following identical language:                                                      
                7.  Reserve for accrued vacation pay (sec. 10121 of the                      
                     bill and sec. 463 of the Code)                                          
                                        Present Law                                          
                     Under present law, an accrual-method taxpayer                           
                generally is permitted a deduction in the taxable year                       
                in which all the events have occurred that determine                         
                the fact of a liability and the amount thereof can be                        
                determined with reasonable accuracy (the "all-events"                        
                test).  In determining whether an amount has been                            
                incurred with respect to any item during the taxable                         
                year, all events that establish liability for such                           
                amount are not treated as having occurred any earlier                        
                than the time economic performance occurs (sec.                              
                461(h)).  With respect to a liability that arises as a                       
                result of another person's providing services to the                         
                taxpayer (such as the liability to provide vacation pay                      
                in exchange for service by an employee), economic                            
                performance generally occurs when such other person                          
                provides the services.                                                       
                     In order to ensure the proper matching of income                        
                and deductions in the case of deferred benefits (such                        



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011