Lucky Stores, Inc. and Subsidiaries - Page 4

                                        - 4 -                                         
               Rule 201(f) of the Federal Rules of Evidence provides that             
          judicial notice may be taken at any stage of the proceeding.                
          Petitioner's Judicial Notice Motions will be denied in this case,           
          however, because their many paragraphs constitute nothing more              
          than a hodgepodge of argument and statements with respect to the            
          alleged action or inaction of respondent's counsel, of other                
          taxpayers, and of Congress, and with respect to collectively                
          bargained multiemployer pension plans.                                      
               Unfortunately for petitioner's position is the overlooked              
          central fact that section 404(a)(6), from which the disputed                
          administrative pronouncements have flowed, is a timing provision,           
          not a free-standing substantive provision intended to override              
          other deduction provisions of section 404(a).  Section 404 is               
          entitled "DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTIONS OF AN EMPLOYER TO AN                  
          EMPLOYEES' TRUST".  Section 404(a)(6) is entitled "Time when                
          contributions deemed made" (emphasis added).                                
               The private rulings attached to petitioner's various filings           
          all uniformly hold that post-yearend contributions (grace period            
          contributions) to a qualified employees' benefit plan (including            
          in some cases multiemployer plans), if made within the parameters           
          spelled out in section 404(a)(6), may be deducted in the prior              
          year, but only if they fall within the deduction limitations of             
          section 404(a) and related subsections.  Since petitioner's                 
          Motion and the Judicial Notice Motions never address this all-              
          important proviso, petitioner's claim, even if correct, that                




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011