Dudley B. and La Donna K. Merkel - Page 37

                                        -37-                                          
          Although the testimony presented by petitioners indicates that              
          SLC may have been experiencing some cash-flow problems after the            
          agreement, SLC apparently had sufficient liquidity to pay both              
          Dudley Merkel and David Hepburn hefty salaries for SLC’s fiscal             
          years ending February 29, 1992, and February 28, 1993.  We take             
          those payments as some evidence of the nonprecarious financial              
          situations of both SLC and petitioners on the measurement date              
          and during the 400-day workout period.  The fact that the 400-day           
          workout period had 371 days to run on the measurement date is a             
          fact to be taken into account, but it does not convince us, as              
          petitioners suggest, that the probability of a demand for payment           
          under petitioners’ guarantees (as renegotiated) was 92 percent.             
          The State tax assessment was ultimately abated, and petitioners             
          have failed to convince us that such result was not foreseen.               
          Considering all of the evidence, petitioners have failed to                 
          persuade us that a bankruptcy event was likely to occur.  Such a            
          finding is not inconsistent with the testimony of Robert Kennedy            
          and David Hepburn that the possibility of bankruptcy was “real”             
          and not “insignificant”.  Therefore, petitioners have failed to             
          prove that, as of the measurement date, they would be called upon           
          to pay any amount as a result of petitioners' guarantees.                   
                    3.  State Tax Exposure                                            
               The State tax assessment became final on June 14, 1991, in             
          the amount of $980,511.84.  As in effect and in relevant part,              






Page:  Previous  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011