Estate of Artemus D. Davis, Deceased, Robert D. Davis, Personal Representative - Page 41

                                       - 41 -                                         
          NYSE.  Most of those partnerships were making distributions to              
          their partners (distributing limited partnerships) as of the                
          valuation date.  In examining the trading transactions of the               
          limited partnership units, Mr. Pratt focused on those transactions          
          involving publicly registered limited partnerships that, like               
          ADDI&C, were not making distributions to partners (nondistributing          
          limited partnerships) as of the valuation date.  After studying             
          the data relating to the trading transactions of the limited                
          partnership units, Mr. Pratt made a number of different                     
          calculations regarding the amounts of discounts from net asset              
          value at which those units were trading, including separate                 
          calculations of the median amounts of the discounts from net asset          
          value at which limited partnership units of distributing limited            
          partnerships and nondistributing limited partners were trading.             
          Although Mr. Pratt reproduced in an exhibit to his expert report            
          the data from the document (source document)21 that he had used in          
          making those calculations, he did not use the average discount              
          that was printed in the source document and that was based on the           
          average of the range of trading prices for each of those units              
          that were reflected in that document.  Instead, Mr. Pratt admitted          


          21  Mr. Thomson included in his rebuttal report a copy of the               
          source document from which Mr. Pratt obtained data with respect             
          to the publicly registered limited partnership units that he                
          examined.  That document provided the name of the limited                   
          partnership, the value per limited partnership unit, the range of           
          prices at which that unit traded, and the average discount                  
          reflected in the trading price from the value of that unit, which           
          was computed by using the average of that range of prices.                  



Page:  Previous  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011