David R. Green and Carolyn B. Green - Page 14

                                       - 14 -                                         

          deliberation was limited to a cause of action under a breach of             
          contract theory.                                                            
               Moreover, in the Jury Instructions with respect to                     
          petitioner, the Jury was instructed to deliberate based upon only           
          a breach of contract cause of action.  The Jury was specifically            
          instructed that "in awarding damages, if any, you are not                   
          permitted to award any amount for the purpose of punishing any              
          party, or to make an example of any party."  There were no tort             
          or tort type cause of action instructions to the Jury with                  
          respect to petitioner.                                                      
               As noted, the District Court's Judgment also is devoid of              
          any reference to an award based on a tort or tort type claim.  In           
          addition to the $159,238, the Judgment awarded only amounts of              
          commissions plus interest to petitioner and FBC.  The Judgment of           
          $1,521,628.04 was based solely on breach of contract claims.                
               After the Jury Trial, WNIC was faced with a liability of               
          $1,521,628.04, in favor of petitioner and FBC.  This Judgment               
          reflected commissions due, interest thereon, and an amount for              
          wrongful termination of the general agency contract.  Obviously,            
          WNIC thought it could reduce this liability by its appeal of the            
          Judgment.  Petitioner did not appeal.  After settlement                     
          negotiations, WNIC was able to settle for $894,800.00, a                    
          reduction of $626,828.04.  WNIC's liability as a result of the              







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011