Mel T. Nelson - Page 35

                                       - 35 -                                         

          further remaining debt discharge amount is disregarded, i.e.,               
          does not result in income or have other tax consequences.’”                 
               This language of the legislative history evidences an intent           
          to preserve the notion of section 1.61-12(b), Income Tax Regs.:             
          “Income is not realized by a taxpayer * * * as the result of an             
          adjudication in bankruptcy, or by virtue of an agreement among              
          his creditors not consummated under any provision of the                    
          Bankruptcy Act, if immediately thereafter the taxpayer’s                    
          liabilities exceed the value of his assets”, at least to the                
          extent that there are no more tax attributes to adjust under                
          section 108(b).                                                             
               I therefore join the majority in rejecting petitioner’s                
          argument that COD is one of the “items of income (including tax-            
          exempt income)” mentioned in section 1366(a)(1)(A) that is passed           
          through to the shareholder(s).  In so doing, I disagree with                
          petitioner’s corollary conclusion that all items excluded from              
          gross income under sections 101 through 135 of the Code must be             
          treated as the same kind of “tax-exempt income” under section               
          1366(a)(1)(A).6                                                             

               6 I agree with respondent’s argument that the location of              
          sec. 108 with other Code provisions, such as secs. 101 and 103,             
          in subtitle A, ch. 1, subch. B, part III, entitled “Items                   
          Specifically Excluded From Gross Income”, does not require that             
          all such sections be treated in identical fashion for the                   
          purposes of applying sec. 1366(a)(1)(A).  See sec. 7806(b) (No              
          inference, implication, etc., as to legal effects to be drawn               
          from arrangement, classification, location, grouping, descriptive           
                                                             (continued...)           




Page:  Previous  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011