Estate of Robert W. Quick, Deceased, Esther P. Quick, Personal Representative, and Esther P. Quick - Page 7

                                        - 7 -                                         
          level proceeding.  See, e.g., Woody v. Commissioner, 95 T.C. 193,           
          206 (1990).  However, the determination of any overpayments must            
          be included as part of the decision in this case after a trial on           
          the merits.  See sec. 6512(b)(3); Estate of Quick v.                        
          Commissioner, supra at 189.  Pursuant to section 6512(b)(1),                
          petitioners would be entitled to a credit or refund of any                  
          overpayment that we may determine only when the decision becomes            
          final.  Further, pursuant to section 6512(b)(2), we may order the           
          refund of any overpayment included in a decision only if the                
          refund remains unpaid for 120 days after the date the decision              
          becomes final.                                                              
               In response to petitioners' argument, even if the                      
          adjustments to the amounts of their distributive share of                   
          partnership losses for 1989 and 1990 were somehow separable from            
          respondent's challenge to the characterization of those losses              
          under section 469, and were therefore subject to computational              
          adjustment, which they are not, we lack jurisdiction under                  
          section 6512(b) to determine any overpayments of tax attributable           
          to computational items at any stage of this proceeding.  Woody v.           
          Commissioner, supra at 206.  It follows that we also lack the               
          authority to order the credit or refund of overpayments                     
          attributable to such computational items.                                   
               Lastly, petitioners' argument that the Court failed to treat           
          the section 469 issue consistently for all years before the Court           
          is unavailing.  We did not conclude that the characterization of            




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011