John T. Talkington and Margaret K. Talkington - Page 24

                                       - 24 -                                         

          Dr. Friedman in valuing the Bates Center.  The cost approach was            
          the methodology most important to Mr. Cantrell in valuing the               
          Bates Center.                                                               
               As Mr. Cantrell states in his report, buildings like the               
          Litton building are built for owner occupants and tend to be                
          owner occupied and not to be rented in the market.  Additionally,           
          Mr. Cantrell's report states that the sales comparison method is            
          generally recognized as being the best method for valuing land as           
          if vacant and ready for improvement to its highest and best use.            
               Based on our review of the record and the weight accorded              
          the sales comparison method by both parties, we deem it                     
          appropriate to set aside the cost and income approach to                    
          valuation in this case.  Instead, we rely on the sales comparison           
          method in determining the value of the gifted Litton property and           
          the Bates Center.                                                           


          IV.  Fair Market Value of the Gifted Litton Property                        
               Mr. Cantrell determined the fair market value of the gifted            
          Litton property on December 15, 1992, to be $1,805,000.  Dr.                
          Friedman determined the fair market value of the gifted Litton              
          property on December 17, 1992, to be $800,000 (before subtracting           
          costs required to place the building into service).                         
               A.  The 11.656 Acres                                                   
               Under the sales comparison method, Mr. Cantrell determined             
          the fair market value of the 11.656 acres (which was 507,728                



Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011