John T. Talkington and Margaret K. Talkington - Page 27

                                       - 27 -                                         

          unreasonable, and we shall not apply an adjustment for time.                
          There was a slow market for land in the neighborhood in which the           
          Litton property was located, and since 1984 Lubbock had virtually           
          no growth.                                                                  
               After removing Dr. Friedman's time adjustment, the adjusted            
          sale prices of the four comparables he used are $0.24, $0.25,               
          $0.25 and $0.38 per square foot.                                            
               Based upon our review of all the valuation evidence, giving            
          due consideration to our observation at trial of the witnesses              
          for both parties and considering their testimony and the expert             
          reports, we conclude that the 11.656 acres was worth $0.28 per              
          square foot for a total value of $142,164.                                  
               B.   The Litton Building                                               
               Under the sales comparison method, Mr. Cantrell determined             
          the fair market value of the Litton building (which was 48,215              
          square feet) on December 15, 1992, to be $819,655 based on a                
          value of $17 per square foot.  Under the sales comparison method,           
          Dr. Friedman determined the fair market value of the Litton                 
          building on December 17, 1992, to be $723,225 based on a value of           
          $15 per square foot.                                                        
               Mr. Cantrell compared the Litton building to five other                
          comparables which were as follows:                                          
               Building   Sale Date   Bldg. Size (Sq. Ft.)   Price Per Sq. Ft. For Bldg.
               LB1       12/88     72,500              $12.69                         
               LB2        3/90     24,140              28.47                          
               LB3        1/89     26,505              41.58                          
               LB4        9/92     10,850              6.08                           
               LB5       12/92     34,560              12.17                          



Page:  Previous  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011