John T. Talkington and Margaret K. Talkington - Page 34

                                       - 34 -                                         

          to the airport.  TA2 was located closer to Lubbock's central                
          business district than the parcel of 30.3 acres, and therefore              
          Dr. Friedman applied a negative location adjustment of 50 percent           
          to TA2.  TA3 was located on the access road to Loop 289 and was             
          much closer to Interstate 27 than the parcel of 30.3 acres.  Dr.            
          Friedman, therefore, applied a negative location adjustment of 10           
          percent to TA3.  TA4, located one-half mile from the parcel of              
          30.3 acres, had access to MLK but no frontage on Loop 289.  Based           
          on these facts, Dr. Friedman applied a positive location                    
          adjustment of 30 percent to TA4.  We are convinced that the                 
          adjustments Dr. Friedman made for location are appropriate,                 
          except we believe that the adjustment to TA2 was excessive.  We             
          believe that a negative adjustment to TA2 of 20 percent is more             
          appropriate.  We shall use these location adjustments in order to           
          determine the value of the parcel of 30.3 acres.                            
               Dr. Friedman also adjusted the comparables for size.  He               
          applied a positive adjustment of 10 percent to TA3 because it was           
          approximately twice the size of the parcel of 30.3 acres and a              
          positive adjustment of 30 percent to TA1 because it was much                
          larger than the parcel of 30.3 acres.  We are convinced that                
          these adjustments are reasonable and accept them in order to                
          determine the value of the parcel of 30.3 acres.                            
               Dr. Friedman also made a "site" adjustment to TA2 because              
          TA2 was a pit.  He applied a positive adjustment of 20 percent.             
          We are convinced that an upward adjustment is appropriate because           



Page:  Previous  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011