Central Reserve Life Corporation and Subsidiaries - Page 22




                                       - 22 -                                         

               identically). * * *  [Id. at 1036-1037; fn. refs. and                  
               some citations omitted.]                                               
               Our conclusion that the term “total reserves” does not                 
          include accrued unpaid losses is also supported by examining the            
          structure of the statute.  The applicable statute, section 816,             
          treats the class of “unpaid losses” as a subset of a much larger            
          class of items called “reserves”.  An insurer’s “total reserves”            
          are defined by section 816(c) to include its “unpaid losses”, and           
          the latter term is followed in the text by a clause that reads              
          “and * * * all other insurance reserves required by law”, sec.              
          816(c)(3).  The fact that an accrued unpaid loss is not a reserve           
          in the pertinent insurance industry means that it cannot be                 
          included in a subset of reserves, nor followed by “other                    
          insurance reserves”.  Moreover, an insurer’s “unpaid losses” are            
          added to its “life insurance reserves” under section 816(a) to              
          reach a sum that must “comprise more than 50 percent of its total           
          reserves”.  Sec. 816(a).                                                    
               Our interpretation is further supported by the fact that the           
          word “reserves” had acquired a fixed and definite meaning in the            
          life and A&H industry at the time of the 1942 Act.  The 1942 Act,           
          as discussed above, added the term “unpaid losses” to the Code,             
          and the legislative history surrounding the 1942 Act contains no            
          indication that Congress intended to use the word “reserves” in             
          other than the meaning that was then crystallized in the life and           






Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011