Daniel Francis Kelly, Jr. - Page 14




                                       - 14 -                                         

               Leaving aside whether petitioner's initial act in procuring            
          the room was primarily for his personal purposes, the Court is              
          satisfied from the record that petitioner's second trip to the              
          hotel room, at which time a sexual offense purportedly occurred,            
          was the action that gave rise to the sexual assault claim, and              
          such action was driven primarily by petitioner's personal                   
          motives.  The Court so finds.  At this second visit, petitioner             
          and Ms. Doe were admittedly alone in the room.  If petitioner               
          made this second visit out of his concern for Ms. Doe, he did not           
          indicate that he would do so to Ms. Johnson, whom he had just               
          dropped off at the Sports Bar.  On the contrary, petitioner                 
          stated to Ms. Johnson that he was going home.                               
               Moreover, while in the room, petitioner admitted to contacts           
          between him and Ms. Doe that were clearly well beyond the realm             
          of ascertaining Ms. Doe's well-being and clearly unrelated to               
          petitioner's trade or business.                                             
               GBC's elevator policy in effect at the time of the incident,           
          with which petitioner contends he was complying, stated as                  
          follows:                                                                    

               I.   OBSERVANCE OF INTOXICATION                                        
                    A.   Previous intoxication                                        
                         1.   Personnel are directed to closely                       
                              observe all patrons at any Pointe bar.                  
                         2.   Insure that our bartenders are not serving              
                              alcoholic beverages to already intoxicated              
                              individuals                                             




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011