Estate of Helen J. Smith, Deceased, Frederic L. Foill II and Cassandra F. Vallery, Co-Executors - Page 3




                                        - 3 -                                         
          one-third of the shares of stock.  At the time of her death,                
          decedent owned one-third, or 195, of the total 585 shares.                  
               The farm was situated on approximately 1,300 acres, half of            
          which were bottomland subject to flooding and half of which were            
          forest and pasture.  JFI was actively engaged in farming, with              
          earnings for the years from 1988 through 1992 varying from a low            
          of $9,243 in 1990 to a high of $28,145 in 1992.  JFI paid                   
          dividends only in amounts sufficient to meet its shareholders’              
          tax liabilities with respect to JFI’s operations.  JFI’s farming            
          operations were managed and conducted by an unrelated individual            
          serving as farm manager pursuant to a contract of indefinite                
          duration.  The manager was compensated with a salary and various            
          benefits, plus a 5-percent share of farm profits.  On the date of           
          decedent’s death, the undiscounted value of JFI was $1,818 per              
          share.                                                                      
               On the estate tax return, petitioner claimed a value for               
          decedent’s shares in JFI of $331.94 per share.  In the notice of            
          deficiency, respondent valued decedent’s shares in JFI at                   
          $1,636.32 per share.  Respondent now concedes that the value of             
          decedent’s shares in JFI is no greater than $1,029 per share.               
                              ULTIMATE FINDING OF FACT                                
               The fair market value of decedent’s 195 shares in JFI at the           
          date of decedent’s death was $439 per share, or a total of                  
          $85,605.                                                                    






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011