Estate of John L. Baird - Page 11




                                       - 11 -                                         
               Mr. Young also discussed other factors that might affect the           
          amount of the discount, such as tract size, lack of management              
          control, the number of coowners, and the cost of acquiring a fee            
          interest.  He did not, however, provide any guidance as to how              
          those factors should be taken into account in valuing the 16                
          parcels of timberland under consideration.                                  
               Although the six sales of timber properties cited by Mr.               
          Young occurred in northwest Louisiana, respondent contends that             
          there has been no correlation to the 16 parcels of timberland we            
          consider in these cases.  In addition, respondent points out that           
          Mr. Young, in his discussion of the practicality of partition,              
          assumed that the partition would result in 65 shares.  That                 
          assumption tends to exaggerate the cost of partition.                       
               With respect to Mr. Young’s comparables, respondent provided           
          some information about each reflecting that the fee value used by           
          Mr. Young could be too high.  Any reduction in the fee value used           
          would accordingly and proportionately reduce the percentage                 
          discount that could be attributable to a fractional interest.3              






               3 Mr. Young also provided a report in which he commented on            
          various assumptions that had been provided by the estates’                  
          counsel.  It was not evident how Mr. Young’s comments were                  
          formulated and why he would be qualified to opine on certain of             
          the assumptions.  Accordingly, we do not rely on his commentary             
          concerning the estates’ assumptions.                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011