Estate of Marcia P. Hoffman, deceased, Elisabeth Hoffman, Personal Representative - Page 26




                                       - 26 -                                         
          is no evidence that these notes were subordinate to the notes               
          payable to decedent and Hoffman Associates.  The main asset of              
          Clubside was the Cathead property, and Clubside’s available cash            
          was negligible as of the valuation date.  However, as of the                
          valuation date, Clubside’s asset-to-liability ratio was                     
          approximately 3 to 1, and Clubside had the option to prepay the             
          notes in full or in part, without penalty, at any time.  There is           
          no evidence in the record to indicate that the promissory notes             
          would not be honored by Clubside as of the date of maturity.  We            
          believe that a willing buyer would consider all these factors in            
          determining an appropriate rate of return on an investment of               
          this nature.  After reviewing the reports and testimony of both             
          parties’ experts, we agree with respondent that a 12.5-percent              
          rate is appropriate and hold that the values of the promissory              
          notes payable to decedent and Hoffman Associates were $56,664 and           
          $91,070, respectively, as of the valuation date.                            
               2.  Value of 27.5-Percent Interest in Clubside Partnership             
               At the time of her death, decedent held a 27.5-percent                 
          interest in Clubside.  Respondent determined that decedent’s                
          interest was worth $338,000 as of the valuation date.   The                 
          estate determined that decedent’s interest was worth $290,582 as            
          of the valuation date.20                                                    

               20At trial, Mr. Bishop admitted that he erred in his                   
          analysis because he did not properly account for the value of the           
                                                             (continued...)           





Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011